The Electronic Entertainment Expo trade show in Los Angeles earlier this month had Sony, Microsoft, and Nintendo facing off against one another in a battle for gaming supremacy. Most gamers won’t get to make a decision until the Xbox One and PlayStation 4 hit store shelves later this year, but that didn’t stop TBS late-night host Conan O’Brien from traveling to the show to pick his favorite.

As it turns out, the giant redhead is rather fickle.

Check out the host meeting with Bayonetta, playing indie games, and crushing it at Mario Kart 8: