This is part of our ongoing series about games and trends of the upcoming next generation.
With the next generation of consoles due in a little more than a week with the PlayStation 4’s debut, the launch lineup is firming up. A little over a week ago, 2K Sports held a press event outlining their plans for next-gen basketball, starting with NBA 2K14. Last week, EA revealed their NBA experience with NBA Live 14. Now that we’ve seen them, how do the new generation of sports titles stack up thus far?
Let’s take a look at both soon to be released basketball games and break down their advantages and content packages. We’ll see who has the edge over which game aspect and find out if there is enough data to determine a clear king of next-gen hoops.
Online action
EA brings Sports Hoopsnet, where players will find the home for all things involving online play. The head-to-head feature not only has seasons but even an tournament mode and ladder rankings. It’s reminiscent of Battle.net, Blizzard’s all-in-one online hub for games like StarCraft II, one of gaming’s e-sports stars. And NBA Live 14 appears to be going for similar aspirations.
And like its EA Sports brethren, Madden NFL, NBA Live 14 now boasts its own Ultimate Team mode, in which players unlock virtual card packs to form their ideal hoop squad. That means, yes, you can have a future Dream Team of your own, with Kobe Bryant, LeBron James, Tony Parker, Dirk Nowitzki, and Ray Allen as your starting five. You can also play against former and current NBA teams and other players’ teams, too. NBA 2K14 has a similar offering through its MyTeam mode, with its own tournament mode and head-to-head action, but 2K has yet to fully detail that content. Based on what we do know, both modes seem fairly similar, but without 2K’s full disclosure, Live 14 gets the advantage here.
Edge: Live 14.
Above: 2K14’s MyCareer mode offers depth in choice and consequence.
Career modes
Comparably, Live 14’s answer to 2K14’s MyCareer mode, called Rising Star, gives players an opportunity to create their own NBA legacy. Similar to MyCareer, Rising Star also begins on the road to the NBA Draft. Failing to reach the draft is a possibility in 2K14’s career mode, but it’s impossible to fail in Rising Star, EA tells us. However, you can drop from the first to the second round, which will affect your playing time and starting role eligibility.
Or you can take a more linear route, as Rising Star helps you manage a career spanning 25 years. MyCareer’s nonlinear course offers more narrative and choice in this regard and has over 40 hours of play in the first season alone, but it’s unclear how many seasons the game offers. EA has the depth as far as longevity goes, with 2K potentially offering an equally dense experience albeit within a limited number of seasons, but again, we can’t be sure what that limit is. It may come down to what’s important to you as a player: Do you enjoy a longer experience or more choices?
Edge: Tie.
Who makes a better GM?
NBA Live 14 does have a GM and Dynasty mode, where you manage an organization, including player contracts, trades, and ticket prices. It’s all very similar to NBA 2K14’s MyGM mode. Both features reward you for good management, and bad administrators likely get fired. Either way, both look to be on equal footing in this arena.
Edge: Tie.
Above: Live 14’s dribbling is a hybrid between real world physics and arcade rules.
Dribbling details
NBA Live 14 takes a more “thoughtful” approach, as EA Sports executive producer Sean O’Brien describes it. Movement is based on real-world physics. So if the player onscreen is standing still or turned away from the basket, you can’t just make a beeline in full sprint to the rim, like in previous versions. You have to consider the player’s position and actually build up the momentum necessary for offensive aggression.
This new level of play really does require thought as you attack or defend the basket. Same can be said of dribbling, which works under the same principle and is much more technical. When it comes to ball-handling, every player now has six signature dribbling moves, regardless of how their real-life counterpart plays. And the general controls contain three tiers of dribbling, which progress in finesse and execution. NBA Live 14 may adhere to real-world physics in terms of mobility, but as far as skills go, the game definitely sticks to an arcade style.
2K only permitted the press to play 2K14 for 2 minutes, so we’re unsure how deep the gameplay goes, but we do know that it’s based on authenticity. So a sharp-shooting center like Nowitzki won’t have the same shot-blocking skills as the Warriors’ Andrew Bogut, a more traditional big. This category may also come down to player preference: Do you want a more authentic NBA experience, or a technical, arcade feel?
Edge: Undecided.
Above: Live 14, like 2K14 also uses real world connectivity to enhance the NBA experience.
Data dishing
NBA 2K14 couples its EcoMotion game engine with Stats Inc., one of the biggest sports statistics companies in the world, to translate real-life NBA occurrences, such as offensive and defensive streaks, into the gameplay; NBA Live 14 employs this same aspect through an exclusive partnership with Synergy Sports Technology, the very same analytics company that all 30 NBA teams use for scouting. As Synergy collects data from real NBA contests, information will then upload to Live 14 within an hour after each game, affecting player performance for better or worse, depending on the situation. It’s much like 2K’s NBAToday feature, except NBAToday gets real-time updates. Instant gratification is a big part of gaming, so it’s hard to see players get keen about waiting for real-world game data after an NBA contest has finished.
Edge: 2K14
The next-gen look
The biggest glaring difference between these two basketball games lies within graphics. 2K14 has advantage on all visual fronts. This doesn’t mean that Live 14 looks bad, because it’s definitely a step up from current-gen visuals; however, 2K14’s motion capture of nearly every NBA player really stands out. It even accurately portrays the pros’ playing styles and shooting mannerism, along with the details of the league’s stadiums and crowds. The authenticity is just stunning.
NBA Live 14 exhibits great sprites, too, but according to EA, the designers did only a fraction of the motion capture with real NBA players that 2K did, using in-house talent for rest of the animations. Again, Live 14 looks next gen, but it doesn’t have the life-like appearance of it’s competitor.
Edge: 2K14
Above: NBA Live 14 looks next-gen, but NBA 2K14 is life-like, visually.
The championship package?
While 2K appears to have a couple of advantages, NBA Live 14 certainly presents an appealing package. Live 14’s online is completely revamped with pro gaming in mind, an exciting feature. Controls are manageable for causal players but have enough depth for devoted fans.
Even though NBA 2K14 is still somewhat shrouded as far as its full feature set goes, there’s nothing hidden from the visuals. The graphics are marvelous from any angle. And the gameplay, as 2K Sports describes, is designed to mimic the real world, which is where all that motion capture really pays off. How that translates into gameplay has yet to be revealed, but we’re told to expect authenticity.