The Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky Second Chapter has been a long time coming. Though released in Japan back in 2006, an English translation of the game has taken years to complete, due to various obstacles and restructuring the translation team faced (you can read more on that story here). And with the coming deluge of JRPGs, it seemed fitting we’d get a game to remind us why the genre’s so great.
Second Chapter, available now on PSP (reviewed), Vita (thanks to backward compatibility), and PC, features an enormous world filled with dozens of characters to talk to and all sorts of parts unknown to uncover. In my 78 hours with the game, I saw of lot of fun, intimate moments propped up by a great main cast and even better supporting one. These characters fleshed out their world and made it seem much larger than the areas I visited. This world reminded me why I loved inhabiting these fanciful realms.
[aditude-amp id="flyingcarpet" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":1841592,"post_type":"review","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']But though I liked a lot of what it had to offer, Second Chapter also showed me why they don’t make games like this anymore. And for most of my time with it, but I slogged through it, waiting for the moment it would end.
Check out our Reviews Vault for past game reviews.
What you’ll like
The world and characters make you care
Second Chapter makes a big deal out of creating a large, overarching world with a rich political history. Even though the plot uses the conflict between the countries of Liberl and Erebonia as a backdrop to the main plotline revolving around the mercenary Bracer organization, you get a great sense of the region’s history. My story was only a small part of this world, even as that late became key to its survival. It has too many other people with their own problems to think otherwise. What’s more, I wasn’t pushed to solve most of them, but rather observe.
Nothing makes this shine through more than Second Chapter’s characters. Although many of them fall into JRPG tropes (the spunky hotheaded heroine and her stoic boyfriend, the angry bruiser, the martial arts master, etc.), the dialogue between them makes you feel like all the characters live in a world existing outside of these conversations. It has the occasional long-winded explanation to a character that feels out of place, but for every one of those, a dozen or so conversations play out naturally.
I’ve never played the first chapter of Trails in the Sky and have likely missed a lot of the nuance of a few character interactions, but the moments I felt the world was at its most real was when Estelle, the main character, reunited with a new party member I’d never heard of before. It was as though I was taking a vacation with someone returning home, and it showed how much thought developer Nihon Falcom has put into creating moments that have little to do with plot but make every character more relatable.
This is all amid a world-ending conflict, and these moments made me understand why fans were so desperate for this sequel — not for a resolution to the larger story, but for its myriad smaller ones. Even not having played the first game, I wanted to know where these characters would end up.
You don’t have to suffer too much if you don’t want to
[aditude-amp id="medium1" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":1841592,"post_type":"review","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
The characters and the world they inhabit set Second Chapter apart from its JRPG competition, and it looks like Falcom knows that. No matter what difficulty you’re playing on, you have the option to lower it for any encounter that gives you trouble before you retry, and on one occasion, I could continue without having to face a particularly difficult boss toward the end. Because the combat system doesn’t live up to its ambitions (more on that later), I appreciated the ability to power through some of the harder fights.
And because of the number of party members you have at your disposal (and because you can only take four of them out at a time), I also appreciated the leveling system, which greatly accelerates the amount of experience an underleveled character gets. Certain parts of the story required that I add to my party a character I’d completely ignored until then, and by the time I got rid of them, they were on par with the rest of my party without me having to go out of my way to level them up.
Above: Second Chapter’s ingame style uses 3D polygons mixed with 2D sprites. (Screenshot is from the PC version)
What you won’t like
Death by a thousand shortcuts
Second Chapter begins just as Joshua (one of the first game’s main characters) discovers he’s been the unwitting puppet of Ouroboros, an illuminati-like organization, and suddenly leaves Estelle (the other main character) behind to deal with the repercussions of his absence. At first, I thought this was an interesting twist since JRPGs rarely follow each other this directly (instead choosing to create brand-new, self-contained scenarios). But it quickly devolves into another save-the-world plot. Estelle rebuilds her party from old and new friends and sets off to stop the world from ending. Even as I started, it felt like I’d done this a dozen times before — not a good start.
[aditude-amp id="medium2" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":1841592,"post_type":"review","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
And while I liked many of the characters, others felt like plot conveniences to help writers create intense moments without earning them. Joshua specifically made me roll my eyes countless times, as his newfound omnipresent awareness allowed Second Chapter to create inescapable situations for the rest of the main cast, only to have him swoop and find an impractical way of getting everyone out unscathed. Other characters also perform some questionable leaps of logic that lead to them being on opposing sides. The plot prioritizes having a few key moments play out and then takes the easier, less convincing route to get there.
Second Chapter also feels like it takes a few shortcuts when it comes its structure. It simply doesn’t do enough with its own formula to really differentiate from other JRPGs; even series as old as Final Fantasy or Dragon Quest have found ways to keep their core conceits fresh by reinventing themselves. In Second Chapter, however, you’re following a quest line from town to town, and the first 40 or so hours felt like an absolute grind even though I was ignoring most of the monster encounters. You venture into a city, do a few part time jobs as a Bracer, solve a mystery if you want to, and then head toward the end-of-chapter boss, telegraphed from miles away.
This is the most standard of JRPG setups in both plot and structure, and it doesn’t do anything to make them worth revisiting.
[aditude-amp id="medium3" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":1841592,"post_type":"review","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
Above: Trails features an character customization system using orbs to grant both stats and spells.
The combat system lacks finesse
Second Chapter’s combat borrows a lot of concepts from a standard strategy-RPG template: it’s turn-based, but characters move and attack on a grid. The turn order alludes to Final Fantasy X, where spells take a certain number of turns to charge, while others grant more turns or slow down others. Certain attacks and spells have areas of effect, so where each party member stands during a given turn makes a difference. I had fun figuring it all out at first, but it buckles under the weight of a few puzzling decisions.
You can move or attack in the same turn. When you attack, you do move to the target, but you don’t get to choose from which square you fight. You can ignore this aspect of combat early on, but later bosses make dodging their big attacks crucial to surviving the fight. Say, for example, an enemy standing next a party member is about to fire a laser that will kill them. On that party member’s turn, you can’t choose to have them circle behind them and attack from safety; the “move” command would let you get behind the enemy but not attack. Many attacks also push enemies in particular direction, so that you can’t choose from which direction to attack means you can’t choose to push enemies into spells they’d otherwise avoid. Seeing that the enemy can do exactly this makes the inability to do it all the more frustrating. But for whatever reason, you can’t.
Without that degree of finesse, the combat system feels far too simple to really make a case for how much time you spend fighting monsters. Because all of the combat takes place on a grid, it takes longer than usual for battles to play out. And the longer I spent in these battles, the more I wanted to just skip every fight and just get to the next story sequence. A few bosses take advantage of the grid-based combat system (one boss constantly push you around the map, preventing you from casting spells on your allies), but for the most part, I wondered why the grid was even there.
It has hints of potential (the upgrade system lets you customize characters, but this amounts to which character you want to cast which spells), the combat system doesn’t go far enough in fleshing out its own potential, and it suffers as a result.
Above: Combat takes place in open areas, and many attacks can hit multiple targets if set up properly. (PC Version)
The filler
[aditude-amp id="medium4" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":1841592,"post_type":"review","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
Second Chapter also resembles other JRPGs by being long as hell, and a lot of it is filler Even worse, many of the quests involve your party simply moving from one part of the map, starting a story sequence, then moving back to the original point. An entire chapter revolves around your party making the trek back through every city you’ve already visited by foot (where before you flew from town to town via airships) in order to restore power to a telephone in each city. The last few boss fights end up being harder versions of boss fights you’ve already fought, except with higher numbers across the board. This made my much of my time in Liberl feel like a chore.
Feeling like you’re out of the loop
Trails in the Sky consists of one story told across two games. I haven’t played the First Chapter of Trails in the Sky, and while I didn’t have much trouble getting up to speed on the story, the game did I assume I’d seen the first half of the story. I never got objective markers telling me where to go (which I actually appreciated, since it let me explore), but often, a character would tell me to go to specific place without much direction, assuming I already knew how to get there. This makes sense in world, since Estelle knows how to get around, but I felt like perhaps the first game had laid out where everything was and assumed I knew that already. So if you’re interested in jumping into this game, be prepared to play an entire other game before you can truly feel comfortable in this world.
Conclusion
In a year filled with enormous time-sinks that make their worlds rich and worth exploring (Bloodborne, the Witcher 3, Fallout 4), Second Chapter simply isn’t worth your time if you’re not already invested in its characters or its world. Though it’s technically a 9-year-old game, it feels far older, stuck in many of the conventions other RPGs from around the world have already moved past. If you have to see how the story ends, it’s worth seeing through, but everyone else should look for something else to spend this much time with.
[aditude-amp id="medium5" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":1841592,"post_type":"review","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
Score: 57/100
Legend of Heroes: Trails in the Sky Second Chapter is available now for PSP, Vita (through backward compatibility) and PC. The publisher provided GamesBeat with a copy of the PSP version for this review.