Check out our Reviews Vault for past game reviews.
When I booted up Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 2, I prayed for the best. I hoped that someone was brutally honest with MercurySteam, the developers of the Lords of Shadow series, and gave them the constructive criticism that they needed to hear. Someone who could point out the specifics on why the original action-adventure game fell way short as a Castlevania experience.
[aditude-amp id="flyingcarpet" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":974694,"post_type":"story","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']I also prepared for the worst: the possibility that all of the odd 80s and 90s review scores out of 100 that the first installment received from critics were seen as a giant green light for the design team to deliver more flawed gameplay.
Just so my fears are clear: The original Lords of Shadow was one of my biggest disappointments in the world of Castlevania. It was a visually stunning yet monotonous, confused, and creaky amusement park ride that padded its length with tedious busy work. MercurySteam was trying to reinvent Castlevania, but it wound up with an oddly paced regression instead.
Publisher Konami releases its sequel today for PlayStation 3, Xbox, and Steam. And I’m no longer worried.
What you’ll like
Above: PFFFT! What are the chances that I am going to get struck by ligh…
Improved structure
MercurySteam’s first good move was to go to the drawing board, rip the restrictive chapter-centric level design off the table, wad it up, and slam it into the Konami break room garbage can. The key to Lords of Shadow 2 settling into a more enjoyable Castlevania experience revolves around going back to a Metroid-influenced level structure. Although the game is still linear in nature, guiding me down a walled track from point A to point B, the road widens and curves into itself, encouraging a lot more exploration. It also lays out the right bait to tease me into willfully backtracking later on, with the promise of an item just out of my reach or the possibility of a shortcut between sections.
What little backtracking was required to finish the main campaign did not feel like a miscalculation of the layout or padding for extra play time. I never felt like completing a section in the main mission gained me the reward of a U-turn back from where I came, which can be a trap of this layout even in 2D. When I did wind up in situations where I was crossing familiar ground, it was always as a short junction to something fresh.
Most importantly, this structure gives LoS2 a much more consistent pace, with a momentum that is always moving and avoids the abrupt halts that the previous game’s chapter system created.
More whipping, more precision
[aditude-amp id="medium1" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":974694,"post_type":"story","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
Above: So much more enjoyable than climbing.
Another benefit of this level structure is all the opportunities it provides for large groups of monsters to jump my ass. Transitions between major combat areas, such as platforming and puzzle sections, didn’t keep me preoccupied from fighting monsters for too long. When backtracking through a section, a group of creatures is always ready to respawn back in to tear me apart. At a later point in the main mission, Lords of Shadow 2 also begins to do a bit of creature-type rotation in certain sections, adding just a little bit more variety to some of the encounters.
LoS2 also adds a Challenge mode, which appears when you unlock the Chupacabra shop (an in-game store that appears about one-third into the main mission). This mode provides a set of arena showdowns with various mobs of creatures going up against the player. Each challenge also has a set of objectives that are related to the combat system, such as not using any special items or maintaining your focus meter, which requires filling with consecutive successful hits on an opponent without receiving damage, for a certain amount of time.
The combat system itself is one of the very few things from the original Lords of Shadow that I am happy to see carry over to the sequel. You can unlock a healthy collection of moves across the three main weapons (Shadow Whip, Void Sword, and Chaos Claws), with a combo system that feels very forgiving about when an attack string can cancel into another. This also includes canceling into a dash, block, or parry, which allows for a very versatile toolbox for maintaining focus meter in most situations.
The best tweak to the combat system, if not a benefit to the entire game in general, is that the camera is now completely controllable. Don’t get me wrong; a lovingly designed static camera can work for an action game, but the one in the original Lords of Shadow had me doing some guesstimated hail marys in the middle of a fight. Now I can hit a specific target, check behind me for anyone sneaking up, dash out of danger in a very specific direction, and be clear about where my character is facing.
[aditude-amp id="medium2" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":974694,"post_type":"story","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
Tying it all together are boss battles that focus on mastery of the combat system, not so much weird gimmicks. It may not sound different or exciting, but it works so much better here than the overload of climbing or performing of timed-button “quick-time events,” which is what a lot of boss battles in the original revolved around.
Dear MercurySteam boss battle designer: Thank you for cutting down the Shadows of the Colossus-inspired gameplay. Even Death, one of my favorite boss characters in Castlevania, is a one-on-one showdown of fighting styles and not a gigantic dragon skeleton ride. Although you’ll find a “climbing boss” here or there, it is an extremely small part of the overall adventure.
What you won’t like
Above: Crazy Climber 2014
The climbing mechanic
MercurySteam has resurrected only one gameplay mechanic from the original Lords of Shadow that irks the hell out of me: the climbing. The developers have obviously made efforts to improve it, such as the addition of a swarm of bats that will gather around the next object I am allowed to leap to. There is also an ability to outline the climbing path I am expected to take, just in case I find myself hanging over lava from a cracking brick ledge and could really use a hint on what I can or cannot grab onto. Although I find this portion of the gameplay unnecessarily restrictive, tedious, and a drag, these tweaks are at least attempts to get me out of these scenarios as quickly and as painlessly as possible.
[aditude-amp id="medium3" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":974694,"post_type":"story","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
The climbing mechanic’s biggest downfall, however, is a lack of visual and behavioral consistency. When I am allowed to leap and grab onto a specific object, the message I am receiving is that I should be able to then jump to any object like it and get a similar result. This is a gaming sensibility that is, or should be, ingrained in all of us by our first (hopefully quality) video game experiences. Lords of Shadow 2’s climbing mechanic is only consistent at breaking this rule. I often find myself in a situation where the climbing system tells me I can grab, let’s say a beam. Then later on in a completely different section, I spot a similar beam that looks attainable. So I try to grab it the same way I did before, and I fail multiple times, miserably, until I realize that the climbing design has changed its mind and altered its visual rules.
This is a problem that, unfortunately, leaks out of the climbing section and infects the greater Metroid level structure. When I barely make a jump to a ledge that looks similar to one I was able to grab and do a pull-up onto earlier, is it because I don’t have double jump? Or is it because I am not jumping at that ledge correctly? I shouldn’t be wasting time asking this question because of information and feedback inconsistency.
This issue has also created unnecessary backtracking, where I have been in a large area with a lot of stuff that looks climbable, but since a lot of it is window dressing and the game is arbitrary about what I can grab onto, I can unintentionally be made to feel like I hit a dead end. One frustrating detour later, I come back to the area and recheck every prop until standing in a specific spot spawns the bat swarm onto a random object, leading me to a new area. If a Lords of Shadow 3 is on the horizon, the climbing designer and the environment artists really need to collaborate on a solution that is clear and consistent.
Speed bumps
[aditude-amp id="medium4" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":974694,"post_type":"story","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
Above: Could really use an empty cardboard box to get outta this jam.
While no doubt Lords of Shadow 2 is better paced than its predecessor, MercurySteam occasionally throws in an oddity that kills all the momentum: stealth sections. These portions contain creatures known as Goliath Guards who lumber around like Satan’s mall security force, except they are invincible and destroy our hero damned almost instantly on sight. In the presence of these things, the game deactivated most of my attacks. The three solutions for getting around these guys revolve around throwing a Bat Swarm at them as a distraction, standing dangerously close to one to perform a Possession (gain control of a non-player character), and turning into a rat to crawl through the ventilation system. All of these powers are really cool ideas that I wish were implemented more in the other portions of the game and are not what I am complaining about.
The problem is that these sections feel like fat that should have been trimmed from the final version. They are disruptive to the flow and become highly annoying trial-by-error puzzles when a solution involves the damned climbing mechanic. And thematically, the Goliath Guards do not make sense. I’m playing as a character that has kicked the angel of death’s ass and curb-stomped Satan! Why is this one middle-management monster constantly whipping my butt?
Conclusion
I breathed a sigh of relief as I ejected the Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 2 disc from the PlayStation 3. It seems like whatever deity I prayed to for the best-case scenario had heard me. MercurySteam has taken out most of the problem sections inside the original Lords of Shadow’s design document, specifically the loose patch work of several different action genre ideas, and has given Lords of Shadow 2 a much tighter focus.
Going with the Metroid structure allowed so many Castlevania elements to fall into place, especially in the case of the combat and exploration being much more central to the experience. It could’ve been better, but at least if/when I see an announcement for Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 3, my reaction will be excitement, not so much dread.
[aditude-amp id="medium5" targeting='{"env":"staging","page_type":"article","post_id":974694,"post_type":"story","post_chan":"none","tags":null,"ai":false,"category":"none","all_categories":"games,","session":"B"}']
Score: 80 out of 100
Castlevania: Lords of Shadow 2 releases onto the PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, and Steam on February 25, 2014. The publisher provided GamesBeat with a PlayStation 3 copy of the game for review purposes. Stephen admits to being a miserable little pile of secrets.
